which neighbor guy hits different and why i'm unwell about it

okay so which one would actually destroy you:

**option 1:** guy who is ALWAYS put together. like obsessively. every detail matters to him. the hair, the watch, the cologne, the whole vibe. then one day you run into him outside and he's in a WHITE T-SHIRT and sweatpants with his hair all messy and natural and he looks genuinely thrown off when he sees you. like he wasn't expecting to be seen like this. but then he walks up closer and says hi with this little smile and instead of that sexy cologne he always wears it's just... shampoo and fabric softener and it HITS different. hits SO different.

**option 2:** guy who literally only wears sweatpants and hoodies. never waxes his hair, never cares, always in slides or sneakers. then one day you see some random silhouette outside and you're like who is that and it's HIM. in a full black suit. CRISP. watch on his wrist. hair actually styled. and when he sees you he smiles a little and looks down slightly and honestly??? it's the sexiest thing you've ever witnessed.

which one actually fucks you up more because i need to know.